Once upon a time, a fine fake-leather Sofa served a Denmark Street detectives' office, enthusiastically cheering on the PIs every time it was sat upon. Tragically, following some minor bomb damage, the Sofa was discarded by its owners. Happily, some cash-strapped Professors rescued it from the trash bin and, after a lot of TLC and adhesive vinyl, the Sofa was reborn. It now provides posterior respite for Faculty and Guests discussing their favorite books, film and television programs.
Wednesday, October 7, 2026
Goblet of Fire-Running Grave Links, Part 3. Arrivals and early days at Chapman Farm and Hogwarts.
Monday, October 5, 2026
Goblet of Fire-Running Grave links, Part 2. Slim pickings at the World Cup and at Rupert Court.
Saturday, October 3, 2026
Goblet of Fire-The Running Grave Links, Part 1: A look at perspective and content in the first three chapters.
Happily, as I started my look at The Goblet of Fire and The Running Grave, I saw that this pairing is no exception. The most notable similarity is that both books start with a somewhat unusual point of view, one of someone other than the protagonists. Goblet of Fire sets up the main storyline by providing first a newsreel-like history of the Riddle family murder in Little Hangleton, followed by the suspicion cast on Frank Bryce and his subsequent discovery of Wormtail and Voldemort hiding out in the old Riddle house. Interestingly, though the end of the scene cuts into Harry Potter's scar-tingling nightmare that he presumably sees through the mental link with the Dark Lord, the narrative presented to the readers is from the perspective of Frank Bryce, including events and thoughts of which Voldemort was unaware. Chapters from the perspective of someone other than Harry are very rare in the Potter series, occurring only in the first chapters of books 1, 4 and 7 and in the first two chapters of book 6.
The Strike series is also usually from the perspective of one of the lead detectives, although other perspectives are more common than in Harry Potter. For example, Book 3 has multiple chapters from the killer's perspective, while Book 6 shows many online chats among the moderators of Drek's Game. The Running Grave opens with a Prologue setting up the detectives' major case, delivered through a series of letters between Colin and Sally Edensor, their son Will, eventual murder victim Kevin Pirbright and Edensor's lawyer, along with some interview excerpts with church principals Noli Seymour and Giles Harmon.Both of these opening, alternate-perspective segments end with a relatively abrupt death. Frank Bryce, like the Riddles of fifty years prior, is Avada Kedavra'ed by Voldemort, and therefore "is dead before he reached the floor." Sally Edensor succumbs fairly quickly to her brain tumor, even though "the doctors thought she had longer." Although neither of these deaths is the major murder our heroes will eventually solve in these books, the story of both deaths is used to set up the major storyline.
Thursday, October 1, 2026
Prisoner of Azkaban-Ink Black Heart links, Part 2: Howlers, bombs and not falling over on purpose.
Thursday, September 24, 2026
Prisoner of Azkaban-Ink Black Heart links, Part 1: Interrupted birthdays and well-deserved vacations.
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban and Career of Evil (Books #3 in their respective series) have one very clear over-arching connection: both stories involve a deranged filler out to kill one of our major protagonists. Of course, there are also some contrasts: in PoA, the identity of the "killer" is known (Sirius Black) but the popular belief about him is false (he is not actually a killer, but a wrongly convicted prisoner and he does not want to kill Harry, but rather to save him from the real killer, Peter Pettigrew). No one knows the identity of the man stalking and planning to kill "The Secretary" (Donald Laing) until the book's end, but everyone is 100% about his plans to murder Robin; he, unlike Sirius, is actually responsible for multiple other deaths as well. Will Prisoner turn out to also have major connections to The Ink Black Heart, Book 3 on the hypothesized second ring that closes the Cormoran Strike Series? That remains to be seen. Here, I am going to examine the "prologues of both books." This means the part literally labelled "Prologue" in TIBH, covering the Ritz and the aftermath of the missed kiss, Strike's New Year's Eve stakeout and taking up with Madeline, and Robin's trip to Zermatt. For Harry Potter, it is the first four, pre-Hogwarts chapters: Harry's birthday, the visit from Aunt Marge, his flight from Privet Drive via the Knight Bus after blowing her up and his subsequent three-week vacation in Diagon Alley. Obviously, I am taking a risk comparing four chapters each to start with, given that PoA has 22 chapters and TIBH 107. But, so far, the strategy of grouping the pre-Hogwarts segment with the pre-main-mystery section has served me pretty well.
Tuesday, September 22, 2026
Chamber of Secrets-Troubled Blood Links, Part 4: Who are the TB equivalents to Lockhart, Aragog and Riddle?
TB, being much, much longer, naturally, has a lot more happening:
- Strike's second interview with Janice
- Robin's meeting with Brian Tucker
- the joint interview with the Bayliss sisters
- Strike's Easter journey to Cornwall for the scattering of Joan's ashes
- Charlotte's suicide attempt
- Robin's divorce settlement
- the interview with Betty Fuller
- the disaster with Oakden at the American Bar
- the wonderful Chapters 58-59 with both Strike and Robin's declaration of friendship and Morris's sacking
- Robin's visit to Mucky Ricci and the subsequent row with Strike
- Robin's meeting with Jemma and the resolution of the Shifty case
- the trip to Skegness and meeting with Douthwaite
- the Facetime with Gloria Conti and subsequent resolution of the conflicting clues
- Strike's masterful showdown with Creed, which leads to Louise Tucker's remains
- the discovery of Margot's body at the Athorns and
- the final confrontation and arrest of Janice.
The novel then gives us a two-part conclusion, first the detectives' meeting with the Phipps, Kim and Oonaugh Kennedy, then Robin's birthday, with Strike finally putting some sentiment into gifts and taking her to buy her own perfume.
The major point that struck me as the resolutions of all the mysteries unfold is that, once the truth about characters is revealed, some of the major villains start making pretty strong matches for each other. Take Lockhart, for instance, When comparing CoS to The Silkworm, it is clear from the beginning that Lockhart is an analog to Michael Fancourt, the "vainglorious" bestselling author. We can even connect their names: Fancourt is described as having a shard of ice in his heart, while Lockhart spends a lot of energy courting his fans. But, once unmasked as a fraud, I thought dear old Gilderoy made a convincing match with a superficially unlikely TB baddie. Find out who after the jump.
Sunday, September 20, 2026
Chamber of Secrets-Troubled Blood Linkages, Part 3: Floods, hearts and visits to the past.
Thursday, September 17, 2026
Chamber of Secrets-Troubled Blood Connections, Part 2: The cauldron runs dry.
Tuesday, September 15, 2026
Chamber of Secrets-Troubled Blood links, Part 1: Books of dark magic and mysterious, spooky messages.
Sunday, September 13, 2026
Philosopher's Stone-Lethal White connections, Part 6: The Trapdoor and the Dell
This is the last in my series of posts on Philosopher's Stone-Lethal White connections. I was pleasantly surprised with how many I found: enough to make me think this isn't completely a pointless exercise and to make me interested enough to continue on to Chamber of Secrets- Troubled Blood links. In the meantime, here's a quick look how the last part of PS ("Through the Trapdoor" and "The Man With Two Faces") compared to the end of LW (Chapter 61, the breakdown on the verge through the epilog.
- I had previously compared Aamir's attempt to attack Strike to Neville's attempt to attack Crabbe and Goyle, but it even more closely resembles Neville's failed attempt to fight the Trio in "Through the Trapdoor." Both rather inexpertly put up their fists in a boxer's pose. And, Hermione's expressed regret at putting the Body-bind Curse on Neville ("I'm really, really sorry about this") is like Strike's guilt at knocking Aamir over. ("If it makes you feel any better, I don't feel good about it.")
Saturday, September 12, 2026
Philosopher's Stone-Lethal White links, Part 5: From athletics obsessions to hidden notes.
Tuesday, September 8, 2026
Philosopher's Stone-Lethal White Connections, Part 4: Rule-breaking, Catullus, asphodel and the ICU
Sunday, September 6, 2026
Philosopher's Stone-Lethal White connections, Part 3: The adventure begins with nightmares, open-sky ceilings and lots of corridors.
It starts with a bit of domestic tension for both our protagonists. The Dursleys, of course, are furious that Harry is going to Hogwarts; Matthew is equally angry that Robin is going undercover in Parliament, considering it tantamount to treason. Both Harry and Robin wind up isolating themselves in their bedrooms as they prepare, Robin by practicing her disguise and reviewing Chiswell family trivia with Strike, and Harry by perusing his books. Both approach the big day with a combination of excitement and nerves. Robin has two panic attacks on her first day; Harry also gets a little panicky, first when he can't find Platform 9 3/4; second when he is thinking he would have to do magic for the Sorting. And, just as Robin awoke with a nightmare on her first day at Parliament, Harry awoke with a nightmare on his first night at Hogwarts.
Thursday, September 3, 2026
Philosopher's Stone-Lethal White connections, Part 2: Moving forward, looking back and why Sam Barclay is Hedwig.
Tuesday, September 1, 2026
A Return to Blogging with a New Test of the Double Wedding Band Model: Looking for connections between Philosopher's Stone and Lethal White.
- first, the new series of Three Broomsticks podcasts I've been doing: looking at connections between the Strike books and the corresponding Potter books, so starting with Philosopher's Stone and Cuckoo's Calling and
- second, the Double Wedding Band model for the Strike series, which hypothesizes that tha last seven books of the series will form a ring structure, much as the first seven did, and as the seven Harry Potter books did. See here, here and here for more information.
Saturday, July 18, 2026
Everybody raise a glass! Two new posts with insights into the past and future of the Cormoran Strike series.
I'm spending lots of time with my butt planted on the Farting Sofa these days, trying to get both some work for my business and some needlepoint completed before the birth of my new granddaughter, now due in slightly over three weeks. But I had to pop in for a couple of celebratory toasts.
First, the latest installment of the Three Broomsticks Podcast has dropped, where I had the privilege of appearing alongside my good friends and fellow Strike Scholars Beatrice Groves and Nick Jeffrey to discuss character and thematic connections between The Cuckoo's Calling and Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone. Even better, my trademark nickname for Matthew made it into the episode title. This is the first in a series of podcasts that will look at each of the Strike books and their connections to the corresponding volume in the Harry Potter series.
Second, "Mr. Galbraith" tweeted the above picture today, with a notation that Robin has one in Sleep Tight, Evangeline. The drink is called "Churchill's Courage" and is a speciality of the Rivoli Bar at the Ritz. What we do not know is if Robin has her drink at the start of STE, when she goes to meet Ryan for his birthday/potential proposal, or later in the book. JKR/RG tweeted some weeks ago that STE was 2/3's complete, and historically, tweets have come from the part of the book currently in progress. It does seem like a pretty powerful drink to have in front of a known alcoholic who is struggling with his sobriety. But then again, we can't deny that Robin needs one after the events of THM.
Monday, February 16, 2026
A Little Strike Chick Humor: Plus, an invitation to share any funny fan creations that you know of.
One of the best parts of being part of a fandom is getting to laugh about your favorite, or sometimes least favorite, aspects of your favorite series. It's why people come up with nicknames for characters like Matthew "Flobberworm" Cunliffe, Sarah Shagsalot, the Kimphomaniac and the SE Files' ludicrous moniker for the Sweary Therapist of Sleep Tight, Evangeline, Dr. Broccoli. A few Halloweens ago, there was a series of very funny adult costume memes created for Strike characters.
So, last week, I responded to the call from The Strike and Ellacott Files to submit pictures of chickens that looked like Strike's assorted girlfriends, I got a little too enthusiastic about the endeavor, and wound up getting asked to submit a guest blog post, which you can find here. Check it out; the article includes a few more of my thoughts on fan-created parody materials, as well as a few other links to some funny fan-fiction and character twitter accounts.
If you know of any other good, fan-created Cormoran Strike humor pieces that are available on the internet, please drop a link in the comments. I've love to have a centralized location for sharing, while we wait for Sleep Tight, Evangeline. It's going to be a long wait, and those of us determined to read the depressing Longfellow poem many need an antidote.
In the meantime:
Subscriptions and comments are easier for some on the Substack version of this blog.
Saturday, October 18, 2025
A Serial Killer's Rebounding Spell: My talk from the 2025 Harry Potter Academic Conference.
I've just finished up with one of my favorite weekends of the year, the annual Harry Potter Academic Conference at Chestnut Hill College. This year I hosted a panel called "The Mirror of Rettopyrrah: Wizarding World reflections in post-Potter books."
My contribution was "A Serial Killer's Rebounding Spell: A Deathly Hallows echo in Troubled Blood."It compares Strike's interview with Creed to Harry's final duel with Voldemort.
Please check it out.
Saturday, April 12, 2025
The Silkworm: Chapters 7-9: Our first looks at Liz Tassel and Kathryn Kent
"No, or I'd've bloody well asked them, wouldn't I? You're the detective, you find him!"
Is it just me, or is Leonora a bit rude here, considering Strike was willing to take this case on with no guarantee of payment?
I also found it interesting that Strike chose to get one of Quine's books--- and apparently one of his worst, The Brothers Balzac--- at this stage of the investigation. While he knows that Quine's disappearance is linked to the controversy surrounding his latest manuscript, there is no indication yet that that the contents of Bombyx Mori itself could be a clue, let alone the contents of a book published some twenty years earlier. This seems to be an effort to "get into the head" of the victim--- much like when Strike reviewed Lula Landry's emails in CC, and Robin sampled Margot Bamborough's favorite perfume and music in TB. Except, Strike doesn't even know he is a victim yet
Re-reads are often notable for the new insights you see in the killer interviews and all the clues that jump out at you. l was struck this time by how dark and disgusting Liz Tassel's office was. Between the puking dog, the shabby decor, the abuse of her staff--- they both are literally having to clean up after her very sick dog--and the hacking cough, it should have been clear there was something really off about this organization from the get-go. While Strike sees the pictures and the dog bed as indicating sentimentality in this Dragon Lady, in retrospect, even Old Beau is being mistreated.
Saturday, March 16, 2024
Strike Book Eight is The Hallmarked Man; What do recent hints mean?
Welcome back to the Farting Sofa Faculty Lounge. I had to take an extensive sabbatical from blogging, thanks to personal and professional obligations and the hassles that are involved in setting up my own business. Happily, I'm now the proud owner of Freeman Davis Behavior Services, life has settled down a bit and I, like Strike fans worldwide, was happy to hear the news today the Strike Book 8 will be titled The Hallmarked Man.
These images are only the latest in hints that have been dropping over the last few weeks. Rowling has changed her twitter header three times since February 1st. The first was a picture of the coat of arms on the Freemason's United Grand Hall in London. The second was of La Coupee, a bridge connecting two parts of Sark, a Channel Island, and the third a sterling silver model ship made by the famous Pairpoint Brothers of London and currently selling for more than $42K.
The tweet announcing the book title was also Sark-related: the collage depicted above that includes a lovely silver bracelet JKR received from her husband as a souvenir of her recent trip there. She has confirmed that at least a few chapters of The Hallmarked Man will be set on the Channel island.
What could this all mean? Well, the two items of fine silver suggest the meaning is the original one for "hallmark": a stamp put on British precious metal goods that certified the purity. Fans who were expecting Strike, Robin and friends to turn up on greeting cards, as commemorative Christmas ornaments or perhaps in a cheesy TV holiday movie will be disappointed.
But, the notion of fine quality silver will no doubt delight the folks at Hogwartsprofessor.com, and other literary alchemy fans. If Strike himself is to be the Hallmarked Man, it suggests the albedo-purification process that was so apparent amid all the river and baptismal imagery of The Running Grave will continue, and perhaps be completed in the next book. Of all the major ideas presented so far, this is most consistent with Kathleen's brilliant "Strike Extended Play" and sets the scene for a two part nigredo in TB and IBH, a two-part albedo in TRG and THM and then completing the alchemical cycle with bookk 9 and 10 as a paired rubedo, or perhaps a citrinitas- rubedo combination. I particularly like the idea of citrinitas, or yellowing phase; something there really wasn't time for in the Harry Potter series.
This certainly fits with what we've seen so far: Strike was emotionally broken down in TB and physically broken down in IBH. He clearly is healing and purifying himself in TRG, with his smoking cessation, weight loss and baptismal purification he undergoes after Charlotte's death. I highly recommend you listen this week's Strike and Ellacott files, with guest Kurt Schreyer for a beautiful analysis of that scene, Plus lots of Shakespeare!
In any case, metal stamped with a hallmark has undergone refining and purification, so, even if the Hallmarked Man winds up being at the center of the major mystery, we can still hope that the title will apply to Strike as well, just as the "Superior Man" epigraphs of TRG did. Silver is a classic albedo color, along with white and water, so a sterling silver ship seems a promising herald of albedo, too. Maybe we'll even get a return of the swans. As for me, I'm still hoping the "silver minnow" memory will resurface.
Another bit of trivia: the makers of the silver ship, the Pairpoint brothers, had offices in Soho, not far from Denmark Street, including on Rupert Street.
According to Jung, just as albedo involves the resolution of the animus/anima conflict, with men embracing their feminine side and vice-versa, the citrinitas is the place to encounter the "wise old man" (or woman) archetype. This could mean Ted still being around to impart some potential wisdom before he succumbs to his vascular dementia, or maybe even a crucial bit of information from Strike's own Deadbeat Dad, Jonny Rokeby. If one of them plays the grey-beard advice-giver in Book 9, then dies, it would fit whith the Double Wedding Band model (see here and here) in a couple of ways.
- First, this would have the mentor/father figure dying in Book 9 (which is Book 6 of ring #2) just as Dumbledore died in Book 6 of Harry Potter.
- Second, would also set the stage for Book Ten to open with Ted's (or Rokeby's) funeral, which ties the 1-4-7-10 linkage to gether , with 1 opening with an engagement, 4 with a wedding, 7 with a christening and 10 with a funeral.
But what about the Freemason building? I suspect that will relate in some way to our heroes' major mystery. As some have pointed out, the United Grand Hall is a popular event venue, so it is possible a visit there would have nothing to do with the Freemason organization itself. But, the most interesting thing about the Freemasons to me is their association with police corruption in the 1970's, apparently as a result of some Met cops being in the same lodges with career criminals. This makes me think of gangsters like Mucky Ricci, whom the police were clearly powerless to stop and makes me wonder if the mystery will involve some dirty cops, past or present. If so, that could certainly complicate things for Robin and Murphy. More importantly, it could be a connection to some of themes of TB, which also involved looking back at police work in the 1970's. That would be an interesting link between the two Book 5's of each ring.
Any other thoughts as to what the twitter headers might mean? We still are no closer to knowing a publication date, though JKR tweeted on February 21st that she had completed Part 6. But, Rowling being Rowling we have no way of knowing if that is part 6 of 7, 9 or many, many more.
Stay tuned.













