Spoiler warnings for The Running Grave

As of Nov. 1 2023, I have removed the blue text spoiler warning from The Running Grave. Readers should be forewarned that any Strike post could contain spoilers for the full series.

Tuesday, October 3, 2023

The Running Grave Initial Read-Through, Full Book Spoilers, Part 8 Analysis, chapters 101-121.

For those of us that thought the mystery might be drawing to a close once Robin 's job at the cult was over, we were wrong.  There's lots more to come.  

Spoilers Below.

It is so good to see Robin back at a team meeting. Her guilt over Cherie's suicide is understandable, but we now know there is a mystery phone-caller in the mix. It did surprise me that top-end secure locks weren't installed on both the office and building doors long ago; for instance, when the Shacklewell rippwe was after Robin. 

I was so happy to see Will and Qing turn up at the office and I fully agree with Strike that Robin probably saved both their lives. Pat is awesome in her response to them. The news that Pat is a great-grandmother is a bit surprising, but not so much when you think that she has her first at 17. Finally, I have no idea if it means anything. but the line about "Will blushed scarlet" jumped out at me. Will Scarlet was one of Robin Hood's Merry Men, along with Little John. 

Just to give you an idea of how emaciated people coming out of the UHC are, note how much people are feeding them. At their drink after Robin's questioning by the police, Strike bought her six bags of crisps.  His record, on the night she told him of Matthew's infidelity, was two. Pat appears to come back with four full-size pizzas to be shared among five people, one of whom is a two year old.  Remember, Robin was "fractionally too thin" at her wedding in 2011, and there's been no mention of significant weight gain since. If she lost 25-30 pounds. she would be pretty emaciated. 

Sir Colin certainly raised an obnoxious elder son. I think he have Phillipa Graves would get along. 

The issue with patient confidentiality is interesting, and, as a licensed mental health professional myself, I would say that Prudence was imprudent to tell Strike she had a client who was ex-UHC, and even less prudent, in the absence of any evidence, to accuse Strike of contacting her. I don't know what mandated reporting laws are in the UK, but in the US she would be required to report anything Flora told her about physical or sexual child abuse or neglect, including underage girls giving birth, medical neglect and underfeeding.It's hard to believe that, after so long treating Flora, nothing reportable had been disclosed. So, for me, the question is not so much why Prudence had never encouraged Flora to report, but why she never did so herself. 

Strike and Robin have become much better at disagreeing, as shown by the lack of major blow-ups over Robin's visit to Prudence and of Strike's wish for Robin to take precautions and avoid solo jobs.  

Strike's conversation with Papa J was amazing, though I was hoping for a much more decisive victory, as with Creed.  I like Pat's husband Dennis and I think his racing pigeon hobby is interesting. 

Will's reaction to Flora at Prudence's is typical of the difficulties of dealing with people coming out of cults, particularly when questions of "doing more harm than good." Hassan's book talks about cults often expelling people with mental illness. Flora's description of the gaslighting is also typical. 

If you are interested in the Pepper's Ghost Illusion, it is the one used at Universal Studios to make people "disappear" into the brick wall at Platform 9 3/4. 

The speculation gets quite extensive once our heroes get back to the office with the McDonalds, and seems to go in many different directions.  I start to share our heroes' fatigue here. 

Names
Rufus: "red-haired"
Tanisha: "ambitious" 
Kayleigh:  multiple meanings, including slender, celebration, and, for you Hagrid fans, "keeper of the keys."
Kim: In English: "royal" in Korean. "gold."
Cochran: "Battle cry" or "crimson" 
Bannerman: "Flag-bearer"
Grierson: "Governor"
Bhakta: "Worshipper"  Interestingly. this is a typical boy's name that the former Rosalind Fernsby is using
Dasa: "Servant of god" 
Rosalind: "gentle horse"
Sanchia:  "sacred, holy"
Dennis: "Follower of Dionysus" 
Ring Strcture
James Edensor's flinging his coffee on Robin and having to be prompted by Strike to apologize evokes the scene on the Red Lion pun in Lethal White, where a stranger spilled orange juice on Robin. 

Flora is not supposed to drink on her meds. just as Billy Knight said at his final meeting with Strike, Izzy and Robin. And, if I recall correctly, this is the only time other than in Lethal White that a gun has been a part of the crimes associatded with the case. 

An explicit connection between Jonathan Wace and Liz Tassel of The Silkworm with their dead, blank shark eyes.  We also get another example of Robin's advanced driving skills when they are pursued by the shooter. 

Strike and Robin have a very late night brainstorming session, following a visit to a wealthy person's home, just as in Lethal White. But, the discussion after in the office reminds me more of the final review of the Margo Bamborough police file, in Troubled Blood. But, by the end Strike thinks he has an answer. 

Literary alchemy
The red- and gold-associated names of theses sections could indicate a shift to rubedo. This could be especially interesting if Kim Cochran is hired in a future book. 

8 comments:

  1. Brilliant catch on Will Scarlet! Given the Robin’s explanation of her “nickname”, the name “Littlejohn,” and the idea of Sherwood Forrest being a safe haven for a tight community living outside society’s laws, I now really want to reread that classic with an eye towards parallels! Unfortunately, I didn’t even finish Aurora Leigh before starting my re-read of Strike & HP to prepare for TRG! Got to sort my priorities and spend more time reading!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Please do! I know zilch about Robin Hood other than the highly adapted children's/Disney productions. I've been focusing on the non-fiction supplemental texts, particularly Hassan's book on psychological mind control, which I want to re-read now that I have finished. That's more up my professional alley.
      I would welcome a guest post on Robin Hood as another inspirational tex. If you are interested, send me a private message.

      Delete
  2. After thorough research, by which I mean some sifting through Wikipedia when I should have been working, I think the Robin Hood connection is through Ivanho, which I now suspect is heavily connected to TRG. In that work, Robin Hood is Robin of Locksley, as in Loxley, Yorkshire. Primary characters include Wilfred Ivanho, Lady Rowena, Robin of Locksley, Littlejohn and Rebecca. A critical point is the independence of Anglo-Saxon Scotland from Norman England, which is analogous to Brexit as well as the conflict between independence and connection. Other themes are sons estranged from their fathers (Ivanho and Robin) and reconciliation. I think Noli’s disparagement of the character Lady Rowena (kind and noble, without substance, like a mannequin - Noli clearly has no idea how much strength is required to be consistently kind and maintain personal integrity’s.) is similar to the denigration of house elves.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kathleen, Thank you, this is fascinating. I did look up Ivanhoe whend Noli mentioned it, but it is one book i have never read. Is Littlejohn a traitor or a spy? (Re)Becca a brainwashed Stepford Wife? I'm sure Beatrice Groves will chime in on this at some point. This is a wonderful discovery and I would welcome a guest post on it. But don't jeopardize your job!

      Delete
  3. I wonder if the character connections aren’t somehow upside down — like how the cult convinces members that bad is good and good is bad and how Strike’s relationship with Charlotte and his mother got him thinking that abuse and withstanding abuse was love. Rebecca in Ivanhoe is written as truly admirable, though her good qualities are often dismissed because of society’s rejection of her religion (Jewish). TRG’s Becca is truly despicable, though she appears admirable and has high status due to her seeming commitment to admirable religious values.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Also, I wonder if the idea *coincidentia oppositorum,* which is mentioned and is (again with my Wikipedia-derived expertise) related to the Jungian idea that the self is composed of opposites - light and dark. Of course, yin and yang is a similar idea, and all these thoughts are related to the philosophy that existence of anything requires the existence of an opposite — e.g. there cannot be light without dark or you can’t understand good without understanding evil. Maybe these thoughts are related to my suspicion that we have some literary parallelism (Ivanhoe?) taking the form of orthogonal or mirrored reflections.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I love this idea. We also have the concept of the Rebis: the coming-together of the male and female, which, in this book culiminates in the capture of Abigail as Daiyu's killer

      Delete
  5. “What seemed wrong was right, you see? … ‘I’m pure spirit, which means I understand that what might seem devilish may be divine,” - Becca, chapter 99
    This whole book is the upside down world.

    ReplyDelete

Comments are moderated.